Indiatimes|The Times of India|The Economic Times|
You are here: News Home » City » Mumbai » Activists seek clarity on relaxation of sound rulesTNN | Sep 1, 2015, 11.25 PM IST
MUMBAI: Anti-noise pollution activists have sought clarification from the government on the four days of relaxation in noise rules for Ganeshotsav.
Sumaira Abdulali, convenor, Awaaz Foundation, said, "The Noise Pollution Rules permit state governments to notify up to 15 days a year for time extension up to midnight for loudspeaker use. It does not permit relaxation of decibel limits applicable between 10pm and 6am of 40dB in a silence zone and 45dB in a residential zone. A Supreme Court order clarifies that the power to notify lies with the state government and this power cannot be delegated. It also clarifies that time extensions do not apply within silence zones."
On Monday, chief minister Devendra Fadnavis held a review meeting of the preparations for the festival. TOI had reported officials saying that district collectors and the police would jointly choose any four days of the ten-day festival for the extension.
Abdulali said data of noise levels during the Ganpati festival in 2013 and 2014 show that when the deadline is extended beyond 10pm, the statutory noise levels are always exceeded "often in silence zones and in police presence".
The NGO, in a letter to Fadnavis, has requested clarification on the measures taken by the state to comply with decibel limits and silence zone restrictions imposed by the noise rules and the Supreme Court.
Copyright © 2014 Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd. All rights reserved. For reprint rights: Times Syndication Service
Mumbai: Locals help turn Shivaji Park into a ‘silence zone’
Badri Chatterjee, Hindustan Times, Mumbai
| Updated: Aug 17, 2015 16:18 IST
In 2008, one of Mumbai’s largest sporting hubs, Shivaji Park in Dadar (West), was used for non-sporting activities for more than 100 days. Angry at the high levels of noise and pollution from the political rallies, residents decided to protect the ground by fighting for it to be declared a silence zone.
Ashok Rawat, a local businessman, studied the chronological events over the decades that made a large portion of the 27.9-acre ground unavailable for sporting activities anymore. He spearheaded the fight to bring back the sporting traditions at the park by reminding authorities of environmental laws being broken with the use of the ground as a centre for political and commercial events.
Rawat, along with a group of residents such as Sharad Dixit, JD Udeshi and Mohan Warde, formed the Wecom trust (Walkers’ ecological movement) that consisted of 20 members. The trust filed a petition in 2009 at the Bombay high court (HC) after the municipal corporation refused to recognise the area as a silence zone.
Ashok Rawat, a local businessman, spearheaded the fight to bring back sporting traditions at the Shivaji Park. (Kunal Patil/HT photo)
“The park is surrounded by a number of hospitals, colleges and 11 different schools, which use the ground for sports and physical education activities. According to the Noise Pollution Rules, 2000, the decibel (db) levels for an area like this is supposed to be 45db. However, until we intervened, noise levels were way above the limit,” said Rawat.
Along with guidance and active support from anti-noise campaigner, Awaaz Foundation, the group was able to measure the exact decibel levels and drafted a strong public interest litigation (PIL).
“I remember measuring noise at a political rally which was more than 100db. The rally would start at 4am in the morning causing severe disturbance to residents for weeks,” said Sumaira Abdulali, convener of the NGO Awaaz Foundation. “Rawat and others are an inspiration for residents of Mumbai. They showed a lot of courage by taking the trouble to stand up against the authorities for what the law clearly states.”
Their efforts were rewarded in 2010 when a HC bench of justice FI Rebello and justice AA Sayed passed an interim order, directing that Shivaji Park and its periphery be declared a “silence zone”, and banning the use of loudspeakers in the area from 10pm to 6am owing to the large number of schools and religious places in the vicinity.Sharad Dixit, trustee, Wecom said, “Right from the days of recurrent political processions till today, Rawat has been putting in tremendous efforts to make life easier for residents of the area. Citizens have to take action in the interest of the area they are living in.”
Originally created in 1925, Shivaji Park has been divided into 37 sub-plots given to 37 organisations including schools, colleges and clubs. Two of the plots, Shivaji Chhatrapati Maharaj Samiti and Udayan Ganesh temple are the only ones not used for sports
currently and one stage used for public processions.
Loudspeakers on only 4 days a year:
After the interim order by the Bombay high court in 2010 directed that Shivaji Park and its periphery be declared a “silence zone”, loudspeakers are permitted on only four days of the year, the sound from which has to be at 45db under the Noise Pollution (Regulation and Control) Rules, 2000 – * Republic Day, January 26
* Maharashtra Day, May 1 * Dr Ambedkar Mahaparinivaran Diwas, December 5 and 6
Other structures dotting the periphery of the grounds include:
* The Samarth Vyayam Mandir (gymnasium),
* Shivaji Park Nagarik Sangh (established in 1947),
* Children’s Park,
* Nana-Nani Park (park for senior citizens),
* Scout’s Pavilion
With a walkway lined with huge rain trees, residents of the area have been focusing on increasing the green cover by installing a sprinkler system.
Shivaji Park Silence Zone Noise Pollution Ashok Rawat
Tackling noise pollution: ‘Track complaints to check effectiveness’
Badri Chatterjee, Hindustan Times, Mumbai
| Updated: Aug 03, 2015 23:27 IST
While the Bombay high court (HC) had put the onus of tackling noise pollution on the police, anti-noise campaigners said citizens also need to keep tracking their complaints in order to check whether the police follow the order.
“The two important parts from Monday’s order that will finally help citizens are – who to complain to and what the law exactly states,” said Sumaira Abdulali, convener, Awaaz Foundation. “However, it is important to see whether the complaints are being followed up.”
Dr Mahesh Bedekar, who had filed a PIL in 2010 asking whether public roads can be obstructed for any kind of celebrations and the violation of noise pollution rules, said, “According to SC guidelines from 2005 based on a World Health Organisation (WHO) report, something related to public health has to be taken seriously.”
Bedekar said the reason authorities had not taken any action in the past five years was because of politicisation of festivals. “Noise levels were purposely being elevated during festivals and since people did not know the rules, they were helpless,” he said.
Tags noise pollution Bombay high court anti-noise campaigners
Awaaz Foundation's anti- noise pollution campaign has been covered extensively in the Press and media since 2003.